THE ONE THAT GOT AWAY

Episode #567 · Written by Chad Oliver · Narrated by Scott Miller

Charlie Buckner knows every fisherman, tourist, and troublemaker who passes through Elkhorn Valley. When another fire tears through a local business, he starts wondering why every new building in town seems doomed to burn. The answer waiting beside Beaver Creek is stranger than anything Charlie expected, and it threatens the future of the valley he depends on.

The One That Got Away by Chad Oliver is funny, clever, and surprisingly sharp underneath its easygoing western tone. Charlie looks like a plainspoken ranch owner, but he understands people better than anyone around him. That talent becomes extremely useful once he discovers that some visitors to Elkhorn Valley are not from anywhere on Earth.

The story turns a quiet fishing trip into a tense negotiation between a stubborn local businessman and a group of alien vacationers determined to keep their favorite destination exactly the way they like it. Chad Oliver balances dry humor with genuine suspense, especially once Charlie realizes these outsiders can erase memories, destroy property, and disappear into the sky whenever they choose.

What makes the story memorable is Charlie himself. He never panics, never acts impressed, and never forgets that tourism is still tourism, even when the customers arrive in a spaceship. While everyone else worries about galactic civilization, Charlie keeps thinking about trout streams, cabins, and who is paying taxes in Elkhorn Valley.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Chad Oliver was both a science fiction writer and a professional anthropologist, a combination that gave his fiction a distinctive voice during the 1950s and 1960s. His stories appeared in publications including The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, Amazing Stories, and Astounding Science Fiction.

Oliver is also remembered for novels such as Shadows in the Sun, Unearthly Neighbors, and Mindswap. Much of his work examined how ordinary people react when unfamiliar cultures suddenly collide, and The One That Got Away delivers that idea through humor, trout fishing, and one unforgettable ranch owner who refuses to be intimidated.

LISTEN TO THE STORY

Listen to The One That Got Away by Chad Oliver — a classic sci-fi tale where alien tourists will do anything to protect their favorite fishing spot.

LOST SCI-FI PREMIUM

ABOUT THE LOST SCI-FI PODCAST

The Lost Sci-Fi Podcast is the most listened-to vintage science fiction podcast in the world. Ranked the #1 Science Fiction Podcast in 43 countries and heard in more than 190 countries, the show has surpassed 4.2 million listens.

Each episode features carefully selected stories from the Golden Age of science fiction, professionally narrated. Timeless storytelling the way it was meant to be heard.

What listeners are saying:

★★★★★ “I love this podcast. A great curated selection of Sci-Fi’s hidden gems. Great stories and top notch narration.”
— Smitty Trt

★★★★★ “I found these stories by total accident on Spotify. That was two months ago and I cannot get enough of this podcast. Scott Millers superb vocal ability and narration is perfectly suited to the fantastic stories on offer. Many thanks for adding a lot of relaxation and joy to my life. Sending best wishes to you Scott from Tipperary Ireland 🇮🇪.”
— Stevie Frog 🐸

Vintage science fiction. Professionally narrated. Carefully curated.

📬 JOIN LOST SCI-FI WEEKLY

40,000+ Listeners Can’t Be Wrong

Get vintage sci-fi stories, podcast episodes, and surprises every Monday.

FREE SCI-FI EVERY WEEK

✅ Check your email and confirm — that unlocks your free sci-fi downloads.

No spam in this galaxy. You can eject anytime.